This is David Kelley's account from our interview, now titled "Why Your Roofing Business Is Losing Money (And How To Fix It)." The facts and quotes below come from that recording.
I worked for Lee Haight at RRCA, and I later took a leadership role at CMR. People want the drama of those offices, and they want to know why so many big Florida roofing companies have gone under. I will tell you what I saw. I will also tell you what I will not claim. I cannot give you a precise readout of either company's finances today. What I can give you is the rule I would not break again, and the leak I still see in shops that think they are already checking their numbers.
Sales will not save you if you cannot control your costs. And a lot of roofers are losing 2 to 3% of their material spend on supplier invoices they already paid.
Watch the interview below, or skip to 10:12 on why big Florida roofing companies went under, 16:29 on the most expensive financial mistake I have made, 28:06 on the 3 supplier invoice mistakes I keep seeing, and 44:31 for real audit numbers.
What I saw at RRCA, Lee Haight's company
After Hurricane Irma, I was managing the office at RRCA. Lee Haight is the owner. We were doing large numbers, in the range of $20 to $30 million a year. I maintained very good cost control there. At the time, Lee was very focused on Sky Diamonds, so I was able to run the office. We had zero debt to the supplier. The salesmen were paid. The transparency on the capouts was very clear. There was a reserve in the bank.
I also want this on the record, the same way I put it on camera: Lee always came up with payment in full, including distributions. After a later change in management, I left. I was off the job for about 6 months, and he still maintained my pay, including distributions, during that period. I later picked back up with the company for a storm in Lake Charles, Louisiana, but I was no longer involved in general management.
When Dmitry asked me about the company's position now, including cash issues, I would not pretend I had a clean answer. "It's hard for me to tell you exactly."
Then I went to CMR
After the New Orleans storm work wore me out, I was living in Mandeville, Louisiana, and I was not looking for a big management job. I reached out to Steve at CMR and asked if there was a position. I would have taken a runner job.
Steve brought me in, gave me a role in Louisiana, and later a title I remember as something like national director of sales and storm sales. The company, at that point, had a lot of health. I was doing specialty work, including slate and copper, and sitting on leadership calls.
On those calls, the person who had built CMR's Florida sales force, "many, many hundreds and hundreds of salesmen," was named Danny. Danny and Steve used to have open arguments over money. After Danny left, Steve asked me to step into the Florida role.
That is when the picture changed. At 14:59, I described accounts getting shut down and having to be rebuilt with suppliers. I stayed almost 2 years. Around the second year, in the third quarter, I was drafting cuts: liquidate vehicles, reduce staff, shrink the operation. I was on a high six-figure salary, and it became clear that I should go for the health of the company. I worked through a quarter of that wind-down.
Do I think CMR will make it? I do not claim to know their position now. After I left, they still had about 2,000 jobs in the hopper, and from my understanding, they completed them. What I will stand on is the shared issue I saw in both places:
"I do know where the problem was in both those companies, or in any company. Most of it has to do with cost control."
If that sounds familiar, it should. We have already covered the same pattern in how a $10 million roofer goes broke, and the longer cut of this interview is in why big roofing companies are collapsing.
Here's what you don't do
Do not assume sales will cover a weak back office. "Sales cures all woes" is, in my words, an absolute falsehood. Efficiency cures all woes. Efficiency with what you have. Sales does not cure what you keep.
Do not let supplier bills sit. The most expensive mistake I have made, the one I cannot blame on anyone else, was not maintaining my supplier bills, not paying on time or early, missing the early-pay discount, and letting a balance accrue interest. That is the primary mistake most companies make.
And do not think you are safe just because you paid the bill. Paying on time is not the same as paying the right amount. If you are not auditing invoices against an agreed price list, you can still leak 2 to 3% in roofing supplier overcharges and never see it in a sales report.
The labor and material math does not leave much room for that leak. The way I have always taught the business, labor should run 32% to 35%. Materials, when I really look at it, run around 36%. That is before commissions, marketing, and overhead. I have seen shops offer the sales rep 70% and keep 30% for the company. They are going to have a hard time staying healthy. It sounds desperate.
Pre-caps, post-caps, and job costing come first
Before I talk about invoices, I want every contractor to cap the job before it is sold, and cap it again after it is built. I walked through that at 24:52.
A pre-cap is the direct cost, labor and material, plus a margin. I use 3 margin numbers: par, the minimum I will accept; means, what I normally get; and a goal. There is no exotic formula. List the materials by parts and pieces, square foot, and linear foot, then add labor.
"I always say, if you can bill it, you can build it."
A post-cap is the after-action review. After the job comes in, find out where you made money or lost money, then apply it to the next jobs. Most storm operators run on perceived profitability. Pre-caps and post-caps replace that feeling with numbers. That is job costing in plain language, and it is also how I first noticed the invoice problem.
I was building a pre-cap with Eric Presley for a retail group when I saw the same part moving around in price. A lead boot was $38 on one job and $47 on the next. That is a price list mismatch. I put it in a spreadsheet. Over a 6-month audit for Green Coast, the company I was working with, I found close to $80,000 in overcharges.
The 3 invoice mistakes I keep seeing
At 28:06, Dmitry asked how a roofer actually loses money on supplier invoices. I do not start with a conspiracy theory. I do not believe the overcharges are intentional. I think they come from inefficiency, and from the supplier's system.
The 3 mistakes are straightforward.
- Simple overcharges. The invoice is not the agreed price. That was the first phrase I used: "Overcharges. Simple overcharges."
- Incomplete purchase orders. "The primary reason they lose money is because they are not sending in a complete purchase order." The example I used is a job that goes in with everything except 3 pipes. The crew picks up the pipes at the desk. The person at the counter does not have the special pricing, and those extra items get billed at ordinary tier pricing, or worse.
- No usable price list. "Many people don't have a price list. That's a primary problem." Some contractors do not know what they are paying. Some suppliers, when you ask for a price list, do not know what you are requesting either. The lists I do see can be bloated with 140 items, or they can have 33 items that are not even what the roofer buys.
If you cannot match an invoice to an agreed list, you are trusting the ticket. That is not a control system. That is how roofing material invoice errors quietly become a monthly habit.
What 2 to 3% looks like in real numbers
Once a price list is in place, the pattern is consistent. At 31:18 I said:
"We're finding that in the beginning it's 2 to 3% almost immediately. So if you buy a million dollars worth of stuff in a month... they would be 3%, $30,000."
I have had no resistance from suppliers when the dispute is presented clearly. Over time, the supplier gets trained and the miss rate drops. Then, for storm companies, it often rebounds the minute they move from one location to another. It goes right back up to 3%.
That is what I saw with Jeremy at Green Coast. In the local Naples market after Hurricane Ian, overcharges ran 2% to 3%, then came down to around 1% once the account was retrained. When the company moved to the next storm, the rate jumped back to 2% to 3%. They were buying a lot of material and running about 30 salesmen. A later 2-year audit for that same customer, after about 4 months on the system, was well over $200,000, and they got credited for it.
At 44:31, I walked through a dashboard from a 4-month period: about $8,500 in recovered credits, and $13,000 in overcharges on $1 million of purchases, which is 1.2%. The contractor will get that $13,000 back, even if disputes take a while, and the fee on that recovery is about $2,800.
Those are my examples, from my customers, on this recording. They are not a guarantee of what any other shop will find. They are the reason I stopped assuming an invoice was correct just because someone in the office had glanced at it.
The fix is Invoice Shield
The tool I built to do this work is Invoice Shield. It is roofing supplier invoice auditing built around the problems I just described: material overcharges, incomplete tickets, price list mismatches, and job costing that does not match what you were actually billed.
The idea was mine. The 3 co-founders are me, Eric Presley, and my nephew, who came in as the programmer. I am a firm believer that a true co-founder should be an equal partner.
You can start at invoiceshield.io with a 30-day free trial and no credit card. After that, it is $10 a month, plus $2.50 for every $1,000 processed. The way I put it on the recording is blunt: "For every $4 I give you, I'm only asking for a dollar back." You can cancel anytime. If you cancel after the trial and already recovered money, keep it.
You can also do what I did first, which is put the price list in a spreadsheet and audit a few months of tickets by hand. I would not tell you a software tool is the only way to check invoices. I would tell you this: if you are not checking invoices against an agreed price, you are probably leaving 2 to 3% on the table.
FAQ: roofing supplier overcharges and invoice auditing
What are roofing supplier overcharges?
They are the gap between the price you agreed to and the price on the invoice. It can be a simple wrong unit price, an item that was never on your price list, or extra material picked up at the desk and billed at a higher tier. I do not believe most of this is intentional. It is usually inefficiency. It still costs you money.
How do I audit supplier invoices?
Start with a real price list, then match every invoice line to that list. That is the core of how to audit supplier invoices. You also have to send complete purchase orders, because the items your crew grabs later are the ones most likely to miss the agreed price. In this interview, go to 28:06 for the 3 mistakes and 31:18 for the 2 to 3% recovery pattern. Invoice Shield does that matching, flags exceptions, and sends a clean dispute package to the supplier.
What causes roofing material invoice errors?
The errors I see most often come from incomplete purchase orders, no usable price list, and simple price mismatches. Storm companies see it twice: once in the first market, and again when they move and the local branch is not working from the same pricing. A part can be $38 on one job and $47 on the next, which is exactly how I found close to $80,000 in overcharges over 6 months at Green Coast.
How much can a roofer recover?
On a first pass, I am finding 2 to 3% almost immediately. On $1 million a month in material, that is $30,000. The Green Coast work started at close to $80,000 over 6 months, and a later 2-year audit was well over $200,000, which they got credited. One dashboard I showed on camera had $13,000 in overcharges on $1 million, or 1.2%. Your number will depend on your volume, your branches, and whether you already have a price list.
How much does Invoice Shield cost?
It is 30 days free, with no credit card. After the trial, it is $10 a month plus $2.50 per $1,000 processed. You can cancel anytime. See the current offer at invoiceshield.io.
The homeowner side of the same interview, including how long a roof should actually last, is in how long should a roof really last, and the 15-year debate. The contractor-facing cut on why large companies come apart is in the main David Kelley interview write-up.
If you are a contractor, start with the invoices you already paid
If you are already buying a high volume of material, do not wait for the next storm to make the books look better than they are. Get a real price list, send complete purchase orders, and let Invoice Shield audit the invoices.
If you also want structured help on accounting, sales, marketing, and operations, start with Roofing School. You can also schedule a call or apply to list your company on Directorii.




.png)




