On Friday, November 13, 2026, the Oklahoma Insurance Department announced that State Farm agreed to a $47.86 million settlement after a market conduct exam found the company improperly denied or failed to pay wind and hail roof claims. The headlines make it sound like a clean win. The catch is in the release.
If the review says you are owed money, you can take it. But to get paid, Commissioner Glen Mulready told FOX23, you will have to release related litigation. Attorney General Gentner Drummond said homeowners must sign away bad-faith claims, and people who already sued State Farm must drop those suits to collect. Unused review money can go back to State Farm. If you already have a lawyer, call that lawyer before you opt in. If you never sued, and you lived with a bad roof after a denial, this review is a door that was closed. Opt in. Send your proof. Take the win that is in front of you.
The official split, from the department's settlement page, is a $35 million minimum for consumer restitution, $10 million for Strengthen Oklahoma Homes, and $2.86 million in fines and exam costs. If approved claims need more than the $35 million minimum, the department says it will agree on additional funds. I think you are looking at $30 million, $40 million, and probably more once this gets moving. Still a small fee for State Farm. They save probably billions, but they pay millions. Not fair, but a win is a win. Take it.
If you are an Oklahoma State Farm homeowner, the window is January 1, 2021, through December 31, 2025. Wind or hail, including damaged shingles that were denied. Claims closed without payment, including partial payments and claims called under the deductible, can be reviewed, as KOCO reported. This is not automatic. State Farm has to send a written notice, approved by the department, by December 31, 2026. Then you have to opt in. Payment is not guaranteed.
I've had my fair share of State Farm denials
When I see a state exam saying roofs had damage and still got no payment, I am not shocked. KGOU reported that Mulready said the exam found nearly two dozen violations of Oklahoma's Unfair Claims Settlement Practices Act. KFOR reported one sample: 27 of 58 roofs had damage and still got no payment, about 47%. That is KFOR's reporting, not a figure I audited.
For years, the story has been that the roofer is greedy. This settlement tells the other side. It is not always the roofer who is the bad guy. I would run with that in marketing materials. The money is very small for the industry. The story is a big win.
State Farm disagrees with the findings and admits no wrongdoing. In a statement carried by KOCO and KFOR, the company said it handled more than 100,000 Oklahoma claims over five years despite $178.5 million in net underwriting losses from 2021 through 2025. Attorneys in this fight have said State Farm saved more than $1 billion by paying less on wind and hail. That is their allegation. They save probably billions, and they pay millions.
The catch, in plain English
Commissioner-elect Bob Sullivan told Oklahoma Politics Today, "Looks like it's a great deal for State Farm." Drummond's lawsuit continues, and we covered that fight in Oklahoma AG Sues State Farm: What Roofers Need to Know. I would not tell you to sign away a live case just to grab the original claim money.
In March 2026, months before this deal, NBC News aired the story of Billy and Lacey Hirsch, who said they had a hole in the roof, still got a "fair condition" finding, and paid more than $22,000 out of pocket. That is backstory, not this week's settlement. When a homeowner can point to a hole in the roof and still get denied, regular people stop believing the roofer is the problem.
Roofing is a marathon, not a sprint
A lot of roofers will not take advantage of this, because most companies do not last. I've seen it said that 90% of roofers go out of business in 5 years. I am not hanging this on that as a studied stat. These are older claims, and a lot of those companies are already gone. If you have been around 10, 20, 40 years, edit your playbook. Offer it to people. Add it the same way you add discontinued shingles and other tools to prove claims.
What homeowners should do
Do not assume the old "no" was the last word. Watch for a written notice from State Farm or the Oklahoma Insurance Department. If you are not sure it is real, call 800-522-0071 or use oid.ok.gov/state-farm-settlement. Mulready warned this could generate scams. Official communication, he said, comes from State Farm or the department. If you opt in, send proof: photos, estimates, invoices, and the original denial. Get organized now.
What roofers should do
You are about to get calls from past customers who just got a letter. Help them find the old photos and invoices. Do not overpromise a full roof. When a carrier mails "you may be eligible" letters, the worst operators follow the mailbox. If somebody is door-knocking a settlement list, treat them like a storm chaser. Add this to your playbook. A win is a win. Take it.
If you need a qualified roofer, use Directorii. Those roofers are qualified and backed by a $30,000 guarantee. Roofers who want to get listed can go to contractors.directorii.com.
FAQ
Who can get a review?
Oklahoma State Farm homeowners with a wind or hail claim from January 1, 2021, through December 31, 2025, closed without payment, including partials and under-deductible findings. See the OID settlement page.
Is the money automatic?
No. You have to opt in after you get the official notice. An independent administrator reviews the file. Payment is not guaranteed.
What is the catch in the State Farm settlement?
To get paid, you may have to release related claims, including a pending lawsuit. Call your attorney before you sign anything.
What if someone knocks on my door about the settlement?
Be careful. Official communication comes from State Farm or the Oklahoma Insurance Department. If you are unsure, call 800-522-0071 or visit the department's settlement page.




.png)






